|



| |
Seven killers were executed
in January 2003. They had murdered at least
12 people.
Six
killers were given a stay in January 2003.
They have murdered at least 10 people.
| Date of scheduled execution |
State |
Victim name |
Inmate name |
Status |
|
January 2, 2003 |
Illinois |
Alvin
Smith
Donna Sauls |
James
Tenner |
stayed |
|
Believing that his former business partner Albert Sauls had alienated the
affections of his former girlfriend Shirley Garza, James Tenner planned and
carried out an execution. Sauls and Tenner operated trucking businesses from the
same building in South Chicago Heights. In his space Tenner set up three ropes
and nooses, each just the right height for the neck of the intended victim. Then
with shotgun in hand he invaded the adjoining premises, finding (as he expected)
Sauls and his employee Alvin Smith. He held the two at bay until Garza and Donna
Sauls, Albert's wife, arrived. Tenner directed Garza and Donna Sauls to bind the
men hand and foot; when that had been accomplished, Tenner compelled Garza to
bind Donna Sauls the same way. All four moved to Tenner's garage, where the
three bound victims were restrained in the nooses designed for them. Tenner then
tied up Garza and constructed a fourth noose for her. After covering his
victims' mouths with duct tape, Tenner delivered a harangue (lasting more than
two hours) about the victims' supposed misconduct regarding both his business
and his personal life, and the Saulses' treatment of Garza. Tenner then moved
Garza to his office and returned to shoot the three remaining victims in their
faces at point-blank range. Smith and Donna Sauls died instantly. Albert Sauls
had been able to free his hands and used his arms to shield his face; he was
left for dead but survived and testified against Tenner at trial. So did Garza,
who was rescued by police after Tenner kidnapped her and drove off. Testifying
on his own behalf, Tenner conceded that he prepared the ropes and shot the
victims; his defense was that he sought to protect Garza from the Saulses and
therefore committed second rather than first degree murder. |
| Date of scheduled execution |
State |
Victim name |
Inmate name |
Status |
| January 3,
2003 |
Ohio |
Leneshia Williams, 17
Jala Grant,
3 |
Jeronique Cunningham |
stayed |
|
A jury convicted one of two brothers accused of fatally shooting
a 3-year-old girl and a teen-ager during a robbery that left six others wounded.
Jeronique Cunningham, 29 at the time, was sentenced to death in the shootings
that prosecutors said happened while he and his brother were stealing drugs and
money from one of the survivors. Vicki Williams hugged her 12-year-old son after
Cunningham was convicted of killing her daughter, 17-year-old Leneshia Williams.
"I hope he receives the death penalty," she said. "It won't bring Leneshia back
but they deserve it." Cunningham and Cleveland Jackson, both of Lima, were
arrested two days after the shootings Jan. 3, 2002. The brothers knew some of
the victims, were invited inside their apartment and even watched television
together before herding the group into a kitchen and shooting them one-by-one,
prosecutors said. Six were shot in the head, including Leneshia Williams and
3-year-old Jala Grant, who also died. One of the survivors who was shot in the
head was in a coma for 40 days while the others weren't as seriously injured.
Some were just grazed by the bullets. Defense attorneys did not dispute that
Cunningham was at the apartment. But they said Cunningham had no intention of
robbing his friends and put the blame on his younger brother. Cunningham never
fired a gun he had with him, defense attorney Robert Grzybowski said. "There was
no plan or purpose on the part of Jeronique Cunningham to cause the death of
anyone," he said. "Cleveland Jackson had a purpose and plan." During the trial,
five victims testified they saw Cunningham shoot. "He shot me. I blanked out.
When I woke up, I saw a bloody mess," said Coron Liles who was shot in the
mouth. Prosecutors said Cunningham forced the victims into a kitchen and hit one
in the jaw with his gun before making them line up against a wall. "This is
absolutely the most cold-blooded, calculated, inhumane murder anyone could
imagined," Prosecutor David Bowers said. Several of the victims were related to
each other, and the others were friends from Lima, which is about 70 miles south
of Toledo. Layshane Liles, who lived in the apartment, had sold drugs to
Cunningham earlier in the day and played video games there, prosecutors said.
Cunningham and his brother then decided to return to rob Layshane Liles,
prosecutors said. *Appeals are still pending in this case and the
execution is not expected to take place on this date. |
| Date of scheduled execution |
State |
Victim name |
Inmate name |
Status |
|
January 8, 2003 |
Mississippi |
George Shelton |
Ronald Foster |
stayed |
|
Ronald Foster was 17 when he was accused of killing George Shelton, an employee
at Hankins Superette in Lowndes County, on June 10, 1989. Shelton's body was
found behind the counter by a customer who contacted authorities. He had been
shot in the head. A Lowndes County jury convicted Foster of the killing in 1991.
Foster turned to the 5th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in New Orleans after a
federal judge in Jackson refused to hear a claim of ineffective counsel. The
Mississippi Supreme Court previously had rejected similar arguments. In June of
2020, the
5th Circuit court upheld the judge's dismissal of his claims of ineffective
counsel. "In essence, what they did was uphold his conviction and death
sentence," Assistant Attorney General Marvin "Sonny" White said. White
said Foster's next steps are to ask for a rehearing before the 5th Circuit and
then ask the U.S. Supreme Court to consider his appeal. In 1997, the
Mississippi
Supreme Court refused to reopen Foster's case. The court had upheld the
capital murder conviction and death sentence in 1994, rejecting Foster's claims
that he was too young when the murder was committed to face the death penalty.
He also challenged jury instructions. Foster came back to the Supreme Court in
May 1996, arguing ineffective counsel at his trial and sentencing hearing. He
was asking for post-conviction relief, claiming that the issue of ineffective
counsel was not known at the time of his conviction. That
appeal also was
rejected. A friend of Foster's testified at trial that Foster had admitted
killing Shelton. Foster claimed Shelton was shot after the two struggled over a
gun Shelton pulled from under the counter. UPDATE: The United States Supreme
Court on 1/7/03 rejected condemned inmate Ronald Chris Foster's request to
review his case. The justices gave no reason for their refusal to hear Foster's
appeal. Monday, Gov. Ronnie Musgrove issued a temporary reprieve to Foster. The
30-year-old Foster was scheduled to be executed Wednesday for the 1989 Lowndes
County killing of convenience store clerk George Shelton. Musgrove said the
reprieve would last until the constitutional questions about Foster's age at the
time of the crime and his mental ability are addressed by the United States
Supreme Court and the Mississippi Supreme Court. Musgrove denied clemency
in two executions last year. He says Foster's case is different because of the
age and mental retardation issues being raised by the inmate's attorneys. |
| Date of scheduled execution |
State |
Victim name |
Inmate name |
Status |
|
January 14, 2003 |
Texas |
Clayton Kenny, 83
Juliana Kenny, 74
Adrienne Arnot, 44 |
Samuel Gallamore
|
executed |
|
On the evening of March 29, 1992, Samuel Clark Gallamore and his accomplice
James John Steiner drove to the private residence of Verle Clayton Kenney, his
wife Julianna Kenney, and their daughter Adrienne Arnot, in Kerr County, Texas,
for the purpose of robbing their home. On their way to the Kenney residence,
Gallamore and Steiner discussed their proposed robbery and decided that if any
of the occupants of the home tried to stop them, they would kill them. When
Gallamore and Steiner arrived at the Kenney residence, they parked away from the
house and walked to the door. Along the way, Gallamore picked up a cedar branch
and handed it to Steiner. Steiner also carried a tire iron. Gallamore knocked on
the front door while Steiner, who was known to the Kenney family, hid out of
sight. After Adrienne opened the door, the two men forced their way in, knocking
her down in the process. Gallamore and his accomplice then began beating
Adrienne and Clayton, who had come to her aid, with the tire iron and a wooden
club. Adrienne struggled for her life, sustaining 12 blunt force blows to her
head and face, and 14 blunt force blows to her upper extremities, back, and
right thigh. Clayton sustained six blunt force injuries to his head. These
injuries were sufficient to cause the deaths of the two victims. Gallamore then
grabbed a knife from the Kenney's kitchen and began stabbing Adrienne and
Clayton. Adrienne sustained a stab wound to her right, middle finger, consistent
with a defensive laceration. In addition, Gallamore stabbed Adrienne twice in
the neck, creating a three-inch wound. Gallamore proceeded further into the
house, where he discovered Juliana, partially paralyzed, immobile in a chair,
and unable to defend herself. Gallamore, wielding the kitchen knife, stabbed
Juliana in the neck. The knife wound would have been sufficient to cause
Juliana's death. Gallamore, however, continued to beat Juliana, hitting her at
least five times with a blunt object. The blows were so powerful that they
created a gaping hole in Juliana's skull measuring 7 inches long by 2 inches
wide. All three victims died. After stabbing and beating all three of the
residents, Gallamore and Steiner took several spoons, cash from Adrienne's
purse, and various small items on display in the house. They buried most of the
items taken from the Kenney residence on property owned by Gallamore's parents.
Much of the detailed and graphic description of the events surrounding these
murders came from Gallamore himself, in two tape-recorded confessions which were
produced for the jury, and from Gallamore's testimony at trial. UPDATE: Death
row inmate Samuel Gallamore says the bloody 1992 slayings of a partially
paralyzed woman, her husband and their daughter didn't have to happen. "Things
went wrong, terribly wrong," Gallamore said last week from death row. "I am
sorry. I have no problem giving my life in payment, but I only have one life and
I take responsibility for all three." Gallamore said his friend James John
Steiner directed him on March 29, 1992, to the rural Kerr County home where the
pair planned a robbery for drug money. Julianna Kenney and her husband, Verle
Clayton Kenney, lived there with their daugher, Adrienne Arnot. "I was under the
impression that people weren't supposed to be there," Gallamore said. "They
were. One thing led to another. Everything happened so fast. I had a split
second to react. I don't know why I made the decision that I did, but those
people had a chance to live. No one had to die. I could have left." Gallamore
and Steiner, who had cared for Julianna Kenney in her home, brutally beat
Kenney's husband and their daughter. Arnot was struck 12 times in the head and
face and suffered 14 blows to her upper body, back and right thigh. Her father
was hit 6 times in the head with a tire iron and a cedar stick. Gallamore then
grabbed a knife from the kitchen and stabbed Arnot and her father. "(Mrs.
Kenney) literally kind-of had to watch everything that was happening to her
husband and her daughter but could not move," Kerr County Sheriff Rusty
Hierholzer said Monday. Gallamore said he killed Julianna Kenney. She was found
with her throat slit and skull bashed with so much force that a gaping hole
measuring 7 inches by 2 inches wide was left in her head. Hierholzer said a maid
who arrived at the family's home discovered the gruesome scene. "You walk into
any crime scene that is as brutal and gory as that one was and it definitely
changes you," Hierholzer said. "It is the type of crime you never forget. It was
just so senseless. It is so hard to understand. She couldn't even defend herself
if she wanted to." It took 18 months for police to track down Gallamore and
Steiner. Gallamore had moved to Chicago, where he was working as a home
repairman. "After the crime happened I wasn't running from it," Gallamore said.
"I wasn't going to turn myself in, but if I got caught, I got caught. It wasn't
something I was proud of." Heirholzer said had it not been for the bloody cedar
stick found with a partial fingerprint from Gallamore in the brush outside the
Kenneys' home, police officers might not have ever suspected the young man who
had previously been in trouble for marijuana possession, resisting arrest and
misdemeanor assault. "We had handled him for some minor offenses, but nothing
anywhere like this crime," said Heirholzer, who was the case's lead investigator
back in 1992. "It was a nightmare. It was one of the worst crimes we have ever
had around here." Kerr County prosecutor Ronald Sutton said Gallamore confessed
to the crime shortly after his arrest. Jurors heard a poem Gallamore wrote from
his jail cell during his trial in which he described the begging and pleading of
"the people I sat and watched bleed. I say I am guilty and that is true. Now I
ask mercy from all twelve of you." Gallmore was sentenced to death on Feb. 3,
1994. Steiner received a life sentence. "My life is worthless since I've done
this," said Gallamore, who says he began using marijuana when he was 5, dropped
out of school as a teenager and often fought to protect his older brother who
was in a gang. "When it comes to having a life, you can pretty much say mine was
a failure," he said. "I was just a mixed-up, confused kid. A lot of it had to do
with the drugs. ... If it wasn't for me shooting the bathtub crank we were
making, I wouldn't be (on death row.)" Gallamore said he and Steiner had been on
a 2-week drug binge the night of the killings and both were high on
methamphetamines. "If I could, I would take it back, not just to save my own
life, but to save everybody," Gallamore said. "I have got people I don't even
know who are crying because of me, because they feel for me or they feel for the
victims. Never in my wildest imagination did I ever think this would cause so
much pain to so many people." |
| Date of scheduled execution |
State |
Victim name |
Inmate name |
Status |
|
January 14, 2003 |
Oklahoma |
Louise Schem,
77 |
Bobby
Fields |
stayed |
Bobby
Joe Fields pleaded guilty in 1994 to the 1983 murder of 77-year-old Louise Schem
in Oklahoma County. Fields was burglarizing Schem's home for money to support
his drug habit when she confronted him, prosecutors say. Fields shot her to
death. On March 1, 1993, Shirley Masterson, Bobby Joe Fields's girlfriend,
invited Fields to party at her duplex. Masterson's Aid to Families with
Dependent Children check had arrived and she planned on using the money to buy
alcohol and cocaine. Shawanda and Yolanda Pittman, Masterson's grown daughters,
and Dia Russell, Shawanda and Yolanda's friend, were partying with Masterson and
Fields. The party continued the next day, March 2, 1993. Sometime around noon,
Fields walked two doors down to Louise Schem's house ostensibly to ask if he
could do yard work for her. She declined. In the mid- to late-afternoon, Fields
went to the upstairs-half of Masterson's duplex to ask Albert Anuario if he
wanted to buy a television and VCR for $70. Anuario, who had also been drinking,
replied that he was interested but that he did not have enough money. Fields
decided to steal Schem's television and sell it to buy more cocaine. When,
around 5 p.m., he again walked down the block to carry out the robbery, he
thought Schem was not at home. He opened the screen door, pushed open the front
door, crossed the living room to the television (which was on), and reached to
unplug it. At that moment, Schem entered the room carrying her .25
semi-automatic pistol. A struggle ensued as the two of them wrestled to control
the gun. Despite the fact that, at the time, Fields was thirty years-old, 5' 7"
tall, and weighed 140 pounds while Schem was elderly, 5' 4" tall, and 114
pounds, their struggle was protracted: it began in the living room, spilled out
the front door and down the steps, and ended on the sidewalk in front of Schem's
house. Robert Vallejo happened to be driving by and saw the final seconds of the
altercation. He testified that he saw them struggling on the sidewalk, heard
Schem cry "Help! Help!", heard a gunshot, and watched Schem fall to the
sidewalk. The government's medical examiner testified that the bullet had a flat
trajectory it entered the back, left-side of Schem's neck, beneath her left
ear, passed through her spinal cord and the back of her mouth, and exited her
mouth, fracturing two of her incisor teeth. The gunpowder residue on the back of
her neck indicated that the shot was fired from six to twelve inches. Vallejo
drove away a short distance, made a U-turn, and returned to the scene. Fields
had fled, but he returned to Masterson's house thirty to forty minutes later. As
he walked in Masterson's back door, the pistol went off. Dia Russell testified
that Fields looked hysterical he was talking fast and breathing heavily.
Perhaps half an hour after returning to Masterson's house, he went upstairs and
sold the gun to Anuario for $40. Shortly after the police and medical personnel
started arriving at Schem's house, Russell took Masterson and Fields to Fields's
sister's house. Russell testified that during the drive Fields said that "he
didn't have any kind of remorse or guilt" and "he wouldn't lose any sleep"
because "white people deserve what they got." (Fields is black; Schem was
white.) In addition, she testified that later, while they were watching a news
story of how the police had arrested a different black man for the murder, he
said that he was "relieved" that he might not get caught and that "he had
thought about being on the television show America's Most Wanted." Two
days after the murder, on March 4, 1993, Fields was arrested and interrogated.
He told the police that, thinking Schem was not home, he went to her house to
steal her television. When she surprised him with a gun, he jumped at her in
self-defense, and they wrestled over the weapon. The struggle spilled out onto
the sidewalk, where he pulled the gun from her hands. As he did so, it went off
accidentally, killing her. UPDATE: Gov. Frank Keating issued a stay of
execution Tuesday for a man who was scheduled to die by injection for the murder
of an elderly woman. Keating said he was issuing the stay because he did not
have enough time to consider a clemency recommendation for Bobby Joe Fields
before he leaves office on Jan. 13 and is succeeded by Brad Henry. Fields had
been scheduled to be executed on Jan. 14. The Oklahoma Pardon and Parole Board
recommended
clemency Monday, urging Keating to commute Fields' death sentence to life
imprisonment. "Because the board's vote came just one week before the scheduled
execution on Jan. 14, there is simply insufficient time to engage in the kind of
careful and deliberate review tat is to be expected in such cases," Keating
said. "For that reason, I have issued a stay of execution, and I will
communicate all pertinent information on this case to Gov.-elect Brad Henry's
transition team, since he will assume the power to act in this case next Monday"
This is the fifth time since Keating took office in 1995 that the board has
recommended clemency for a death row inmate. Keating has only granted one
recommendation, for Philip Dewitt Smith in March 2001. Three of the five board
members voted Monday in favor of clemency. One voted against it and one
abstained, said Terry Jenks, Pardon and Parole Board executive director. Fields,
39, pleaded guilty in 1994 and was sentenced to die for the 1993 slaying of
Louise Schem at her Oklahoma City home. At issue is whether Fields deliberately
shot Schem or
if the gun fired accidentally. At trial prosecutors claimed Fields took the gun
from Schem, then shot her as she tried to flee. At Monday's hearing, Fields'
attorneys said the gun accidentally fired during the struggle, resulting in the
fatal wound. The 10th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals upheld the death sentence.
The state Attorney General's office plans to ask that the board's recommendation
be rejected, said Charlie Price, Attorney General Drew Edmondson's spokesman. |
| Date
of scheduled execution |
State |
Victim
name |
Inmate
name |
Status |
| January
15, 2003 |
Texas |
Adriana Marines, 5 |
John Baltazar |
executed |
John Baltazar was sentenced to death for killing a
five-year-old girl in Corpus Christi. Allegedly
seeking revenge for the beating of his mother by her boyfriend, Baltazar
kicked down the door of the man's sister's home in Corpus Christi and opened
fire, shooting at two children who were watching a videotape of Sleeping Beauty. After Baltazar was found guilty of Adrianna's murder, the girl's mother said she
hoped a jury would decide he should die for the crime. "I want him to get
death," said Matilde Cuellar, Adriana's mother. "Every night I see the same
thing when I shut my eyes." But even a death sentence will not wipe out the
image of the shirtless Baltazar smashing into her home and opening fire on her
child, Cuellar said. That vision, she said, will haunt her the rest of her
life. The jury deliberated less than five hours before delivering guilty
verdicts on one count of capital murder for the death of Adriana and two
counts of aggravated assault for the shooting of her father, Jose Arturo
Marines, and her cousin, 11-year-old Vanessa Marines. On Sept. 27, Baltazar
meant to retaliate against Adriana's uncle, Ted Cuellar, who was reported to
have beaten up Baltazar's mother earlier in the day, according to trial
testimony. After recruiting a friend to back him up and collecting bullets for
his .22-caliber revolver, Baltazar drove to the Marines residence on Panama
Drive, witnesses said. There, those in the home say, he kicked in their locked
door and began firing at Adriana and Vanessa as they watched ``Sleeping
Beauty.'' After shooting Adriana in the head and Vanessa in the chest,
Baltazar continued to a back bedroom where he shot Jose Arturo Marines in the
mouth and neck. During the trial, five people identified Baltazar as the
gunman. Police recovered a footprint on the kicked-in door that matched the
black Nike sneakers Baltazar was wearing when he was arrested hours after the
shooting. Jurors heard that Baltazar had threatened to kill Cuellar if he ever
broke up with Baltazar's mother. And home surveillance equipment at Baltazar's
home, where he was supposed to spend his nights because he was on parole,
showed that he left the home before the shooting and returned shortly
thereafter. Defense attorney Grant Jones tried to persuade jurors that the
shooter could have been Baltazar's backup, Johnny Gonzales, who was sentenced
to 80 years in prison for his role in the shooting, or a 14-year-old who
testified that he waited outside in a car while Baltazar was shooting inside
the home. In the sentencing phase, Jones and co-counsel Mickey Kolpack said
they planned to delve into some of Baltazar's social background in an attempt
to persuade jurors not to sentence their client to death. ``We'll show his
redeeming social qualities,'' said Kolpack, adding that Baltazar had taken
part in educational programs during past stays in prison and in juvenile
detention facilities. Assistant District Attorney Diana McNeill said she and
Chief Prosecutor Gail Sadoskas would go through Baltazar's criminal history
and present witnesses who can speak about his behavior in prison. During her
closing arguments in the trial, McNeill asked jurors to send a message to the
community with a guilty verdict. ``In Nueces County, we do not tolerate people
like him - people who kick in doors and kill a little girl watching `Sleeping
Beauty,' '' McNeill said. After the verdicts were returned, she said the death
penalty is appropriate for a man she described as ``the devil'' who haunts
Adriana's family's dreams. ``If it's not for people like him, who do you use
it for?'' McNeill asked. Baltazar will have spent not quite five years on
death row since he entered the prison system for the killing, a significantly
shorter time than the 10-year average in Texas. Laws enacted at both the state
and federal level have contributed to shorter stays on death row. In 1995,
then-Gov. George W. Bush signed a law altering the timetables and deadlines
for inmate appeals. One year later, former President Bill Clinton approved
legislation that limited federal appeals by death row inmates. Recently,
Baltazar's lawyer requested a minimum 90-day reprieve with the state Board of
Pardons and Paroles. He is also trying to have Baltazar's sentence commuted to
life in prison. In a Dec. 14 letter to the board, Nueces County Chief
Prosecutor Gail Gleimer, who prosecuted Baltazar, wrote that he is a habitual
felony offender and a member of the Texas Syndicate prison gang. "I see no
moral reason to grant leniency," she wrote. An official with the board said a
decision could be made Monday on Baltazar's request for executive clemency. In
the meantime, the Marines family is preparing to travel to Huntsville this
week to witness the execution. Since the shootings, people approach them about
what happened that night. The answer Arturo and Matilda always give is that
it's a long story. Until last week, Vanessa Marines, now 16, didn't want to
talk about it. Not even to her mother. Everyone's recollection about that
night, including Baltazar's, is sketchy. Vanessa Marines remembered Adriana
discussing upcoming birthday plans and the movie just starting when Baltazar
stormed into the living room and shot them. Adriana's mother, Matilda Marines,
said she heard one loud bang. She was in the bedroom watching television when
Baltazar entered their home. Her husband went to find out what happened. But
at that point, Baltazar was near the bedroom door, gun in hand. "I remember
going to the house," Baltazar said. "Then the next thing I remember is the
dude jumping out of his bed, and I shot him." He chuckles when asked why he
fired. "He was a male coming at me," he said. "He was pretty close to me when
I shot him." Arturo Marines still has bullet fragments in his jaw, and his
teeth are crooked. Vanessa Marines also carries a bullet in her chest. Doctors
couldn't remove it sooner because it was lodged close to her heart. Since
then, the bullet has migrated toward her back, closer to her spine. Doctors
hope to remove it when she's older. Until then, the bullet is a painful,
physical reminder that she feels "when the weather changes," she said.
Baltazar, who said he had been drinking since 9 a.m. the morning of the
shootings, is frustrated that his intended target wasn't at the house when he
fired those shots. He went there looking for Adriana's uncle, Narciso "Ted"
Cuellar, who reportedly beat up Baltazar's mother earlier that day. Firing at
the two girls was accidental, he said. "It might have been just reflex," he
said. "It was dark. I don't know. I really don't. I'm sorry for Adriana.
There's not even enough words for me to say how sorry I am for the little
girl. If I wasn't sorry I'd be one sorry dude." Less than a year after the
shooting, a Nueces County jury convicted Baltazar of capital murder and
sentenced him to death. He was also convicted of aggravated assault and given
2 life sentences for shooting Vanessa Marines and Arturo Marines. Johnny
Gonzales, who also stormed into the Marineses' Panama Drive home that night,
was sentenced to 80 years in prison for Adriana's death, 40 years for burglary
of a habitation, 60 years for aggravated assault on Arturo Marines and 80
years in prison for aggravated assault on Vanessa Marines. UPDATE: John
Baltazar had no final statement before his execution on Wednesday evening.
Relatives of Adriana Marines witnessed the execution. A stoic Arturo Marines
comforted his wife, Matilda, as she and her sister, Dalinda Cuellar, sobbed as
the death occurred. Marines said his daughter's 1997 death was no accident.
"He pretty much knew what he was doing," Marines said earlier. "He kicked the
door in and just started shooting. He was executioner. He was judge and jury
for my daughter all in one evening." Baltazar, who was paroled from prison
just two months before the shootings, said he feels bad about killing Adriana
Marines and wounding her cousin, but said he doesn't regret shooting Arturo
Marines. "He jumped up and he was in my face," Baltazar said. "That's why he
got shot." Arturo Marines says Baltazar turned his family's life "inside out.
I don't believe shooting innocent children, or for that matter, anybody, is an
accident," he said. "Why couldn't you go after who you were really looking for
instead of destroying an innocent family the way you did?" Baltazar said he
didn't know the answer to that question. "I've been locked up most of my
life," Baltazar said. "There ain't too much I can say about it." Before the
shootings, Baltazar had pleaded guilty in 1994 to a felony burglary charge and
a felony unauthorized use of a motor vehicle charge. In 1992, he also had
served time for two earlier burglary charges. Between 1989 and 1993, Baltazar
pleaded either guilty or no contest to 10 misdemeanor charges, including four
charges of marijuana possession, three charges of evading detention and a
theft charge. "I already knew that if I was found guilty that I was going to
death row, simply because of my prior convictions," Baltazar said of the
jury's guilty verdict and the death sentence it later handed down on March 11,
1998. "You can't find someone not to be a continuing threat to society with
the record that I have." Baltazar said he wasn't afraid to die but thought his
crime wasn't one he should be paying for with his life. "I'm not one to
sidestep or shy away from my actions," he said. "Every thing I have ever been
down for, if I'm guilty, I admit to my guilt. But I don't think being put to
death for an accidental killing is right." Arturo Marines, meanwhile, says he
hopes Baltazar's punishment will finally help his family to heal. "I'm just
glad it is going to be over," he said. "Hopefully after this, everyone can go
on with their lives. "This is the end of the book." |
| Date of scheduled execution |
State |
Victim name |
Inmate name |
Status |
|
January 16, 2003 |
Oklahoma |
Mark
Gomez, 1 |
Daniel Revilla |
executed |
|
Daniel
Revilla was convicted in 1987 for the Jackson County beating death
earlier that year of 13-month-old Mark
Gomez, the child of Revilla's teenage
girlfriend. Prosecutors say Mark was abused for weeks before his death. A
convicted Oklahoma baby killer who once wanted to die for his crime is now a bit
closer to that old wish. The 10th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals ruled 3-0
against Daniel Juan Revilla in his effort to avoid execution for the murder of
13-month-old Mark Gomez in Altus. The baby, the child of Revilla's teen-age
girlfriend, was beaten to death in 1987. Revilla was 18 and had abused the baby
repeatedly for at least a month, according to court records. The child had many
wounds including bruises, blisters, burns and lacerations. The autopsy of Mark
Gomez showed swelling and bleeding of the brain and a severed liver. Revilla
claimed that he had taken his girlfriend to the clinic for a checkup and left
Mark, only 13 months old, at the house alone. Upon interrogation, Revilla
claimed he arrived home and found the baby lifeless on the floor. He tried to
revive Gomez by hitting him in the abdomen, and when that failed, he placed him
in the bathtub and ran some water over him. In a panic, he accidentally turned
on the hot water, causing burns to the child. He then decided to take Gomez to
the hospital, and while hurriedly leaving the house he tripped and fell on a
concrete floor. He then showed up at the county hospital, running through the
lobby carrying Gomez in his arms, screaming that the child was not breathing.
Revilla escaped from the Jackson County Jail in October of 1987. He apparently
had a girlfriend waiting for him, and the 2 traveled to Mexico. During the
spree, Revilla managed to slip away from law enforcement officials in
Wellington, Texas just a few days after his escape. Mexican authorities captured
Revilla in Acapulco, Mexico. In February of 1988 Revilla reportedly said he was
glad to be on death row because of the privileges he had there. In 1996, after
10 years on death row, Revilla maintained his innocence but told a judge in
Altus that he wanted to stop his court appeals. He said he wanted to die within
60 days. Two years later, however, Revilla began his current appeal. He claimed
that several aspects of the guilt phase of his trial and the penalty phase
violated his constitutional rights. The federal appeals court disagreed in a
34-page decision. UPDATE: A man who brutally beat his girlfriend's baby boy to
death 16 years ago died for the crime Thursday. Mark Gomez of Altus was just 13
months old when he was killed in a beating so brutal it severed his liver.
Daniel
Revilla, 34, denied
intentionally harming Mark. He told authorities he panicked when he found the
boy wasn't breathing and struck and accidentally scalded the child while trying
to revive him. The baby was bruised, burned and had cuts on his thighs and
peeling skin on his chest and groin when he died. An autopsy showed swelling and
bleeding of the brain, along with a severed liver. The boy's father and four
other family members came to the prison to see Revilla die. The U.S. Supreme
Court rejected Revilla's last-ditch plea for a stay Thursday afternoon. At the
time of the murder, Revilla was 18 and working on a farm. The boy's mother
wasn't at home when Revilla said he found the child had stopped breathing.
Revilla told authorities he was trying to revive the baby when he struck him in
the abdomen and then accidentally scalded him with hot water. He said he rushed
from the bathroom and struck the boy's head on the door frame. He said he then
tripped and fell on top of the boy. Mark's mother, Michelle McElmurry, and two
other witnesses testified that Revilla hated the boy because he was not his
child. She told of previous abuse, saying Revilla had shut the baby in a kitchen
drawer, folded him in a hide-a-bed, dunked him in cold water and hung him by his
ankles with duct tape. Mark's father, Juan Gomez, said his son was a playful
blue-eyed baby. The murder took place two days before he was to take custody of
him, he said. "I've got pictures of him from when we were together," he said. "I
look back at those times and I sob. It was a short time, but it was still a good
time." Gomez said he wanted to witness the execution because he thought it
might bring him peace. |
| Date
of scheduled execution |
State |
Victim
name |
Inmate
name |
Status |
| January
22, 2003 |
Texas |
Adeline Waunita Dannenberg
Gloria
Hoopengarner |
Robert Lookingbill |
executed |
| When Robert Lookingbill
was 24 years old, he beat his grandparents with an iron bar as they slept
in San Juan, Texas.
Robert Andrew Lookingbill was living with his grandparents, Lorenz and Adeline
Dannenberg, in San Juan, Texas. Sometime between 12:30 and 1:30 a.m. on Dec.
5, 1989, Lookingbill knocked on the door of an apartment behind his
grandparents' home and told the residents that someone had beaten up his
grandparents. One of the residents testified that he did not think
Lookingbill's voice was very convincing. They followed Lookingbill to the
Dannenberg house. On the way, the man noticed a motorcycle that was not there
when he and and the woman had arrived around 11:45 pm. Upon entering the
Dannenberg residence, the couple observed Lorenz Dannenberg lying on the floor
with blood on his head. They then observed Adeline Dannenberg lying on her
bed. Her face appeared to be badly beaten. It was later determined that both
victims suffered massive head wounds as a result of being struck by a blunt
instrument. Lookingbill informed the man that he had called the police, and
shortly thereafter the police arrived. While the couple waited outside,
Aguilar heard a "metal clinking" noise from the storage shed behind the house.
Officer Gilberto Alaniz testified that he observed no signs of forced entry to
the residence, nor did it appear that the Dannenberg house had been ransacked.
Alaniz saw blood stains on Lookingbill's boots and blood spatters on
Lookingbill's jacket. Alaniz investigated the tool shed twice. On the second
occasion, he saw Lookingbill enter the shed. When asked what he was doing,
Lookingbill indicated that he was nervous and worried about his grandparents.
He was told to leave the shed. A subsequent investigator discovered in the
shed, a metal bar that was 54-inches long, two inches in diameter, and 20 to
40 pounds, on which were blood stains and hair strands. Lookingbill indicated
to Alaniz that he had just arrived at the residence and found his grandparents
in their condition. Alaniz checked the engine of the motorcycle, expecting
that it would be hot if, in fact, Lookingbill had just arrived at the house.
The engine was only warm. The jacket, boots and jeans Lookingbill was seen
wearing the night of the offense were recovered by police. An investigator
discovered $568.31 in the jeans when they were inventoried. Joyce Dannenberg,
the Dannenberg's daughter, testified that her parents received more than $500
in social security income in December, which would have been received around
the first of the month. Her mother usually kept some of the money in her
purse. It was determined that the blood on Lookingbill's boots was consistent
with the blood of Lorenz Dannenberg. The blood on the metal bar was also
consistent with Lorenz Dannenberg's blood. Lorenz survived the attack but
suffered serious and permanent injury. Adeline Dannenberg did not survive the
attack. She died on Dec. 15, 1989. Her treating physician indicated that she
had been treated for fractures of the skull, jaw and hand. Surgery had been
performed to remove bone fragments and a blood clot from the brain. It was the
physician's opinion that the injuries were caused by a blunt instrument. A
pathologist who performed the autopsy concurred that a blunt instrument was
probably the cause of the injuries and further testified that the metal bar
recovered from the tool shed could have caused the injuries. Lookingbill gave
two statements to police on the morning of the offense. In the first
statement, he declared that he arrived at the Dannenberg residence at about
1:15 a.m. on December 5 and discovered his grandparents as the police
subsequently found them. In the second statement, Lookingbill declared that he
arrived at the residence about 1:15 a.m., and that he was "all coked up" and
had been drinking. He retrieved a long metal bar from the garage. In his
confession, Lookingbill stated, "My grandfather was sleeping on the floor. I
approached him with the long metal bar. I just raised the bar and struck him
in the head. I was standing right above him . . . My grandfather did not yell
out. He just groaned in pain. I must have hit him more than one time."
Lookingbill then went down the hall into his grandmother's bedroom and, by
Lookingbill's account, "She was sleeping. I hit her on her head with the same
pipe. It was dark I could not see her but I knew where she was sleeping. She
did not yell out." He took the money in Adeline's purse and then called the
police, after which time he went to the rental residence. Lookingbill
was on parole from a burglary conviction for which he had served about 9
months of a 7 year sentence. Evidence was also admitted that Lookingbill
committed an unadjudicated extraneous assault -- the December 1984 murder of
Gloria Hoopengarner, a neighbor to Lookingbill's grandparents -- and then
bragged about the murder and robbery to several individuals.
|
| Date
of scheduled execution |
State |
Victim name |
Inmate name |
Status |
|
January 23, 2003 |
Texas |
Otis Flake, 65
Unnamed male victim |
Elkie
Taylor |
stayed |
| Elkie Taylor was
convicted in the robbery and murder of 64-year-old Otis Flake in Fort Worth.
Taylor was on parole after serving about 9 months of an 8 year sentence for
burglary of a habitation. On the evening of April 1, 1993, Elkie Lee Taylor
(aka Ronnie Lee Watkins) and an accomplice smoked crack cocaine with an
acquaintance staying at the home of Otis Flake, a 65-year-old mentally ill man.
While at Flake's home, Taylor and his accomplice were observed looking around
the house for things to steal and were asked to leave. Flake's houseguest
departed shortly thereafter. Taylor and his accomplice returned in the early
morning hours of April 2, 1993, and ransacked Flake's house, taking jewelry,
cash, a television, and other items to sell for crack. Flake's houseguest
returned to find the front door open and the house in disarray. She also saw
Taylor and his accomplice coming from the back of the house and called to them.
Taylor had a white bag in his hand. Upon entering the house, Flake's houseguest
found Flake sitting up against his bed. His hands were tied behind his back with
white plastic tubing, his feet were tied together with a coat hanger, and a
T-shirt and two coat hangers were wrapped around his throat. Flake died of
asphyxiation due to strangulation. Taylor admitted to his roommates on separate
occasions that he and his accomplice had committed two murders. The first murder
occurred 11 days earlier and seven blocks down the street. The victim was an
elderly man who lived alone. He was discovered with an apron and a coat hanger
wrapped around his neck. Later, when asked if the police were in the
neighborhood because of him, Taylor boldly admitted that he had wrapped a coat
hanger around a different man's neck and that "dead men can't talk." Taylor
smiled and laughed about his offenses. When Taylor was apprehended after leading
police on a four-hour chase, he was driving the cab of a stolen 18-wheeler. The
chase ended when a Texas State Trooper stood in front of the truck and shot out
its tires with a shotgun, causing the truck to stop. Taylor admitted to police
that he and his accomplice had gone to Flake's house, and that he had tied
Flake's mouth, hands and feet, and that he had taken jewelry, cash, a
television, and other items to sell for crack, netting a total of $16. However,
Taylor claimed that his accomplice killed Flake. Taylor also admitted that two
weeks before, he and his accomplice stole a TV from an 87-year-old man but had
been caught by him in the house. Taylor admitted that he grabbed the man.
However, Taylor again claimed that his accomplice killed the victim with a coat
hanger. Co-defendant Darryl Birdow
received a life sentence for Flake's murder. |
| Date
of scheduled execution |
State |
Victim name |
Inmate name |
Status |
|
January 24, 2003 |
North
Carolina |
Jackie Ransom
Larry Jones |
Henry Hunt |
stayed |
January 24, 2003
has been set as the execution date for death row inmate Henry Lee Hunt. The
execution is scheduled for 2 a.m. at Central Prison in Raleigh. Hunt, 58, was
sentenced to death on December 20, 1985 in Robeson County Superior Court for the
September 1984 murders of Jackie Ransom and Larry Jones. Hunt also received two
10-year sentences for two counts of conspiracy to commit murder. At Hunt’s
state-court trial, the state prosecutor presented evidence that Dottie Ransom
and her husband, Rogers Locklear, hired Elwell
Barnes for $2,000 to kill Jackie Ransom, Dottie Ransom’s other husband. (Dottie
Ransom married Jackie Ransom without divorcing Locklear.) Dottie Ransom’s motive
was to obtain the $25,000 proceeds from a life insurance policy that she
purchased on Jackie Ransom’s life so that she could buy a trailer home. Barnes
recruited Henry Lee Hunt to help in the murder, and on September 9, 1984, Hunt
advised Locklear that he had killed Jackie Ransom "last night" and demanded the
$2,000 payment. Hunt threatened to kill Locklear
and Dottie Ransom if Hunt was not paid within 30 days. The next day, Hunt heard
that Larry Jones, an acquaintance and a first cousin of Hunt’s girlfriend, was
"running his mouth" by talking to the police about who had killed Jackie Ransom.
Hunt told his girlfriend that "he was going to put a stop to [Jones’] damn
mouth" and, on a separate occasion, that he was going to "kill that
water-headed, ratting son-of-a-bitch Larry Jones." During the evening of
September 14, 1984, Hunt, Barnes and Jerome Ratley picked up the unsuspecting
Jones and drove him to a deserted spot where Hunt shot Jones several times,
point blank, telling him, "You don’t eat no more cheese for no damn body else.
I’ll meet you in heaven or hell, one." When the three men dragged Jones out of
the truck, he was still alive, so Hunt shot Jones again in the head. After the
bodies of Jackie Ransom and Jones were later discovered, one in Lumberton, North
Carolina, and the other in Fairmont, North Carolina, 10 miles away, Hunt was
indicted for two counts of capital murder and two counts of conspiracy to commit
murder in connection with the murders. The state court appointed two attorneys
to represent Hunt, and he was tried jointly with Barnes. Following trial, the
jury convicted Hunt on both counts of capital murder. |
| Date
of scheduled execution |
State |
Victim name |
Inmate name |
Status |
|
January 28, 2003 |
Texas |
David
Vela, 20
Brendon Proske, 23 |
Alva
Curry |
executed |
| Alva
Curry was condemned for the October 16, 1991 slaying of an Austin convenience store clerk.
A jury sentenced Curry to death in 1991 for the slaying of David Vela, a
20-year-old clerk at a Texaco station on Techni Center Drive off Ed Bluestein Boulevard
in East Austin. David was alone in the store when the robbery and murder
happened shortly before 2:00 am. A security camera captured the slaying on tape. Jurors
watched as Curry and an accomplice smashed their way through the store window.
Curry then jumped over the counter and put a gun to Vela's head.
Vela complied with Curry's demand that he open the store's cash register, which
held $220. After pocketing the money, Curry turned and shot Vela in the head.
Though he died immediately, Curry and Davis shot Vela 4 more times before
fleeing. In spite of having the tape, which gave investigators a good
description of the 2 assailants, Curry was not arrested until Nov. 8, when a tip
led Austin police to him. In the meantime, Curry and Davis had committed a
similar crime one week later, on Oct. 23,
1991, when they robbed a Payless convenience store. That robbery netted
the 2 less than $75 and left Brendon Proske, 23, dead. Proske, the clerk at the
store, was killed in a similar fashion. The case
against Curry presented by Travis County prosecutors featured the videotape from
the Texaco and Curry's videotaped confession, which he gave the day he was
arrested. The evidence was overwhelming, said Larry Sauer, Curry's defense
attorney at trial. "People who saw the video said they recognized that as Alva
who jumped over the counter," Sauer said. "You can see Alva firing, and the guy
was found there on the ground, dead. It was pretty grainy, but you could still
make it out." The 33-year-old laborer also is serving a life sentence for the
murder of Brendon Proske in another convenience store robbery a week after the
Texaco slaying. Proske, 23, was killed in much the same fashion as Vela in a
robbery that netted less than $75. A jury sentenced Curry's friend, 29-year-old
Mark Davis, to life in prison for his part in the robbery spree. Curry
pled not guilty to a single count of capital murder, but was convicted on Oct.
28, 1992. He was sentenced to death a week later. Curry's lawyer said the
evidence against his client made any defense difficult.
Curry accepts his sentence. "I believe I
deserve to die," he said. "They say you reap what you sow. When you live a life
-- especially out on the streets -- you have a certain mentality that if someone
wrongs you, then that person pays with their life." As
he spoke, Curry smiled often and had the relaxed manner of someone chatting over
a cup of coffee rather than facing death by lethal injection.
Curry said he doesn't know why he killed the clerks, but his life had
just taken a "wrong turn. If I could, I would take
back the nights that all this mess happened. I hope with the help of God the
relatives of the victims can forgive me," he said in an
interview the week before his execution date. UPDATE:
An apologetic former gang member and drug dealer was executed tonight for
fatally shooting a convenience store clerk during a robbery in Austin more than
11 years ago. Alva Curry's execution was delayed about two hours until the U.S.
Supreme Court rejected final appeals in the case. "I pray with the help of God
that you will forgive me for the pain that I have caused your family," he said,
looking at relatives of his victims who watched through a window. "I'm truly
sorry. I wish I could take it back. I just pray and ask you forgive me." |
| Date
of scheduled execution |
State |
Victim name |
Inmate name |
Status |
|
January 29, 2003 |
Texas |
Katherine
Thompson, 46
Shelly Cutler, 32 |
Richard Dinkins |
executed |
|
Richard Dinkins killed Katherine Thompson, 46, and Shelly Cutler, 32, on Sept.
12, 1990, at Thompson's massage therapy clinic in Beaumont. Both Dinkins and
Cutler were clients of Thompson's at Therapeutic Massage, and Dinkins had an
appointment that evening to discuss a bad check he had written to her. Prior to
his appointment with Thompson, Dinkins placed a .357 Magnum revolver and a
.25-caliber automatic handgun in a shoulder sling he wore due to an old injury.
He had purchased the .357 handgun and ammunition a day prior to the offense.
Following a brief discussion about the bad check, a heated argument took place.
Thompson pushed Dinkins toward the door into the waiting room where Cutler sat.
Dinkins stated that Thompson struck his injured arm, hurting him. At some point
during the altercation, both handguns fell from Dinkins' sling to the floor. He
picked up the .25 and fired at Thompson but missed. While attempting to fire
again, the gun jammed. Dinkins then picked up the .357 and shot Thompson in the
upper abdomen and then in the head. Both shots were at close range. Cutler, who
was in the waiting room when the shooting started, tried to lock herself in
Thompson's office. Dinkins fired through a reception window at Cutler, striking
her once in the top of the head. Dinkins then fled in his vehicle as the fire
alarm sounded. Thompson suffered two fatal gunshot wounds, one to her head and
one to her abdomen. She died at a hospital shortly after the shooting.
Cutler, a registered nurse, died the next morning of a single gunshot wound to
the head. Dinkins was arrested after his name was found in an appointment book
at the business. He confessed to the murders after the murder weapon was
found in his truck and blood was spotted on his jeans. A firearms expert
testified that slugs recovered at the crime scene were fired from Dinkins' .357
revolver. An FBI forensic serologist testified that blood found on Dinkins' blue
jeans was consistent with Thompson's blood type. Dinkins had no juvenile
criminal history and no adult incarcerations. He was convicted of theft by a
check in 1986, in Abilene, Texas. He was fined for issuance of bad checks in
July 1990, in Lumberton, Texas. If Kitty Thompson and Shelly Cutler still were
alive, their work likely would continue to revolve around helping people,
friends and family members said. The 2 women, both nurses, had known each other
only briefly when together they became victims of Richard Dinkins' bullets.
Dinkins, now 40, is scheduled to be executed Wednesday for shooting the 2 women
to death in Thompson's Therapeutic Massage offices at 3420 Fannin St. on Sept.
12, 1990. "I was so angry for so long because she helped so many people," said
Diane Shaffer, a friend of Thompson, who was 46 when she died. That anger has
since been replaced by sadness. "Knowing what Kitty was all about, it's a little
difficult to stay angry at something she wouldn't have stayed angry about,"
Shaffer said. "...There's a person who's now gone who could still be helping
people." In addition to nursing, Thompson worked as a substance-abuse counselor
and massage therapist. The night she died, Thompson left Shaffer's offices on
Fannin Street after a private substance-abuse counseling session and headed to
her massage offices a block away. "The last thing I remember her saying is 'Lock
your doors because there's crazies around,'" Shaffer said. But, despite the
comment, Thompson was not a person who lived in fear. "She was an extremely
aware person," Shaffer said. "She was built like a little bulldog." To succeed
in her jobs, Thompson needed, and had, both physical and mental strength,
Shaffer said. "I know when this happened down there she was given no opportunity
to try to diffuse the situation because she was very confident she could do that
with just about anyone," Shaffer said. Dinkins was a 27-year-old assemblies
specialist at American Valve & Hydrant at the time who lived in Sour Lake and
had served in the U.S. Air Force. He had a 6:30 p.m. appointment with Thompson
under a false name. When he arrived at her office, they began arguing then
physically fighting about money he owed her for bounced checks from prior
appointments, testimony in Dinkins' 1992 trial showed. Hidden in a shoulder
sling, Dinkins had a .25-caliber pistol and a .357 Magnum that he bought the day
before. When the smaller weapon jammed, he used the .357 Magnum to shoot
Thompson in the head and abdomen and Cutler in the head. Firefighters found the
two injured women around 8 p.m. when they responded to a smoke alarm at the
office probably tripped by the gun's discharge. Thompson died before reaching
the hospital, and Cutler died the next morning. Cutler, a 32-year-old traveling
nurse who had been in Beaumont only 9 days, was in the office filling out an
application for her 1st appointment with Thompson at 7:30 p.m. Cutler planned to
work in Beaumont for 3 months, then return to Idaho. Cutler loved snow skiing
and worked part-time as a ski instructor, her parents, Marcille and Larry Cutler
of Willow Springs, Mo., said in a telephone interview this past week. She
planned to buy a condo in Idaho to live in half and rent out the other half, her
parents said. As a traveling nurse, Cutler had worked in Hawaii and South Padre
Island, where she could pursue scuba diving and windsurfing, other hobbies she
loved, while earning more money than she could staying in one place. When she
left her parents' home for the last time, "she turned around and said, 'I'll see
you guys Christmas,'" her mother said. "No matter where she was, she'd always be
home Christmas," her father said. "That's probably one of the hardest times for
us." Dinkins has a clemency petition pending with the Texas Board of Pardons and
Paroles but has exhausted all other appeals, said his attorney, J.D. Hamm of
Beaumont. Hamm said he has requested a stay of execution to explore possible
jury misconduct and a change from the death penalty to a life sentence. During
his post-trial investigation, Hamm said, two jurors admitted to him that they
considered Dinkins' silence at trial in determining punishment. Hamm argues that
the possible constitutional violation has not been fully explored during the
appeals process. The board is expected to vote on the clemency petition early
this week. After 12 years of waiting, Cutler's family members are ready to see
the sentence carried out. "None of us feel resentful," Marcille Cutler said. "We
just feel like justice will be served because we're confident that the trial was
a fair trial. The evidence was so overwhelming. We felt like he was guilty and
the jury did too. We just feel like this is justice." Pollie Dean, who
supervised Thompson in her substance-abuse counseling at Beaumont Neurological
Hospital, said the approaching execution date has revived some of the tension
and fear that those who worked near Thompson's offices felt immediately after
the murders. "I believe he deserves it, and I've never been real for or against
the death penalty," Dean said. "But when it hits you personally and you see the
devastation it causes for the entire family and the entire community ... I
wouldn't feel safe with him being turned back out into the community. It is, I
think, what prisons are made for and the death penalty is made for."
UPDATE: Before he was executed, Richard Dinkins declined to make a final
statement, responding to the warden, "No sir" when asked if he wanted to say
anything. In a written statement, however, he asked for forgiveness and
expressed regrets. "I am sorry for what happened and that it was because of me
that they are gone," he said. "If there were any way I could change things and
bring them back I would. But I can't." Dinkins accepted responsibility for
the damage his actions caused but said he had made peace with God and hoped that
"soon everyone will be able to have closure in their hearts and lives."
Last week Dinkins said, "It was my fault. I guess you just say -- stupidity. I
can't be bitter," he said. "I'm the one who put myself in this situation."
|
| Date
of scheduled execution |
State |
Victim name |
Inmate name |
Status |
|
January 30, 2003 |
Texas |
Ronnie Hood
Bennett, 39 |
Granville Riddle |
executed |
| Granville Riddle
was sentenced to death for the murder of Ronnie Hood Bennett, 39. On Oct.
9, 1988, Granville Riddle and a friend, Brad Bybee went out drinking. The two
proceeded to drive to the home of Ronnie Hood Bennett. Bybee remained in the car
while Riddle entered Bennett's home and used a tire iron to strike Bennett on
the head at least 15 times, causing his death. In his initial statement to
police, Riddle stated that he entered the premises through a screen window,
which he pried open with the tire iron. Riddle explained that Bennett became
angry at him for damaging his property and, in an effort to defend himself,
Riddle hit Bennett in the knee with the tire iron. When this angered Bennett
even more, Riddle proceeded to hit him over the head until he died. During the
course of the trial, Riddle maintained that he had consent to enter Bennett's
home when the murder occurred because Bennett was a close friend, akin to a
stepfather. Riddle testified that he took a tire iron with him, which he
intended to use to pry the screen off the kitchen window, but when he arrived,
he found a sliding door unlocked. The kitchen window, however, was found pried
open. In yet another version, Riddle testified that Bennett made sexual advances
toward him and when he refused, Bennett grabbed him, pulled him down, put his
lips on Riddle's ear and a hand on his buttocks. According to Riddle, he then
hit Bennett with the tire iron repeatedly, causing his death. After he realized
that Bennett was dead, Riddle tried to make the home look burglarized in an
attempt to cover up for his actions. Although Riddle admitted that Bennett was
drunk when he arrived, forensic evidence proved that Bennett's blood-alcohol
level was .29 percent. This level of extreme intoxication would have rendered
Bennett unconscious. Bybee testified that Riddle called him into the home,
pointed to a few items piled on the floor, and informed him that the items were
theirs to keep. Bybee also testified that Riddle told him that he wanted "to see
how strong your stomach is," and Riddle hit Bennett in the head once more,
imbedding the tire iron into Bennett's skull. Bybee then secretly left. It was
at this point, according to Riddle, that he panicked, grabbed Bennett's wallet
and his truck, and left. The truck was found the next day, burned out in
a ravine. Riddle was arrested five days after the murder following a
statement to police from the 18-year-old man who drove Riddle to the residence.
That man was initially charged with murder, but the charges were dropped. While
awaiting trial, Riddle escaped from the Potter County jail and was recaptured 3
days later. He had a .22-caliber rifle in his possession and the gun was
traced to a residence Riddle had burglarized during his flight. Riddle had
been on parole for less than 6 months after serving only 2 and a half months of
a 7 year sentence for burglary. UPDATE: "I'm just a normal small town
boy," Riddle, who declined to speak with reporters in the week's preceding his
execution, said on an Internet Web site devoted to prisoners seeking pen pals.
"I am caring and I am considerate." His record disputed that. "He's been a
problem for law enforcement since he got old enough to even think about being a
problem for law enforcement," said Randall Sims, an assistant district attorney
in Potter County who indicated Riddle's first burglary was at age 8. "That's not
good old country boys. That's prison material." Besides numerous burglaries,
including a church, school and a restaurant where his mother worked, he had
arrests for drug possession and auto theft. In April 1988, he was sent to prison
after getting a seven-year term for burglary but was paroled after just 2 1/2
months during a time when Texas was experiencing a prison bed shortage. In
November 1988, the then 19-year-old was indicted for capital murder for killing
Bennett. "It was one of the bloodiest crime scenes I've ever seen in 20 years,"
said Sims, who prosecuted the case. "The (victim's) skull looked like a
volleyball that was a sponge, just holes everywhere." Before arriving at death
row, Riddle, from Stinnett, tried escaping from the county jail numerous times
-- succeeding once for three days. He also attempted to electrify his cell door
with wires from his radio and television and was involved in several fights with
other inmates. |
Page visited
times since 11/20/02
Page last updated
06/18/05 |